Out
of all the musical genres, the most ambidextrous is hip hop. Anything with a
pulse can be sampled underneath a rhyme, as rap is essentially poetry with a backbone.
And as we move further more advanced in technology, we have been capable of
even more extraneous production: sampling music from across the world, from any
time period, and creating new, obscurely unique sub-hip-hop genres and
exploring the many moods and emotions that come attached with each new
additive. But this far push from hip hop’s roots may not be as easily
introduced. Inching further away from the machismo that douses your standard
booming bass and degrading lyrics by sampling piano keys and violins ultimately
add a negative connotation to the genre: soft.
The
occasional hip hop ballad has been the rap artist's way to slam-dunk a one-hit
wonder since 1990s slowjammer LL Cool J paved the way for hip hop/R&B
artists to follow. However, the lines between romantic ballads and a deeper
contextual version of what braggadocio hip hop used to be are becoming more and
more blurred.
Although
rap artists have continually produced more melodic tunes with R&B choruses,
artists such as Kanye West, Snoop Dogg and Nelly have gone as far as to not
only sing the hooks themselves, but to sing entire songs and albums while still
classifying themselves as hip hop artists. Additionally, almost across the
board, rappers from T.I. to Drake create songs with female fans in mind, both
by expressing their sensitive side and by boasting about their ability to satisfy
women.
This
is where controversies rise and the war in hip hop draws between the classic standby
and the frontier runners: what does it ultimately mean for hip hop to have
feelings?
Kanye
West’s techno-motional “808s & Heartbreak,” Drake’s expressive rap/R&B
“Take Care,” and Kid Cudi’s inspiring classic rock “WZRD” are three albums that
prove an open imagination and creative ProTools work can push hip hop from “Hot
in Hurr” to a well-respected, ever-evolving artistic genre.
Kanye West, “808s & Heartbreak”
(Rock-A-Fella Records, 2008)
Kanye
West may never be satisfied. Grieving over his materialistic consumption
in one moment then boasting about his wealth the next, he is driven by ego and plagued
by doubt—contradicting the expected feigned composure of your standard pop star.
He hides behind no pseudonyms or characters, and will not hold back from
telling you how he truly feels about everything. West is also noted to have the
most creative and competitive drive to recombine ideas, challenging hip hop’s
standards, and making the only constant theme throughout all of his albums being
the experience of Being Kayne West.
In
the year of 2008, however, West had nothing to brag about. He and his fiancée
broke up, and his mother Donda West, who raised Kanye alone from the age of
three, died from complications after cosmetic surgery. This whirlwind of
sadness caused West to create the melancholic electronic album, “808s
& Heartbreak,” where he sings us through the entire album. This introspective,
minimal electro-pop record steeped in regret and pain contains even more
self-examination than a typical Kanye West album, and is prime example of the many
directions hip hop can go if we release it from its cage.
At this point in
time, the vocal synthesizer auto tune was relatively new on the hip hop scene.
Used most famously by the lyrically shallowest rap artists such as T-Pain, auto
tune wanes on the tacky side of hip hop traits. But in the context of West’s
“808s & Heartbreak,” (aside from hiding behind it as a vocal crutch) it
almost feels like an “if you can’t beat ‘em join ‘em” approach to the
technique. West, however, finds a new way to it better. He embraces the
different ways the cyborg-soul software sounds to his advantage in this new
genre of emo-electro-R&B, upping the pathos and embodying a cadenced cry.
Through first collective
listen, the album gives off a monotonic drone of the pitch-corrected technology,
orchestral strings, and constant bass underlining erratic beep-boop-bops. But
if each song is taken in separately, the album reveals folds and layers that
shows West actually paid close attention to each production detail—it just
needed a little selfless detangling. The record “Street Lights” has an
invigoratingly-pattering drum pulse that beats through atmospheric vocals and
piano scales underneath his vocodored cadence, “life’s just not fair” perfectly
embodies West’s depressed stage.
The
track “Coldest Winter,” dedicated to his late mother, also effortlessly
translates West’s emotional outcry. Its haunting refrains that inhale and
exhale in between bursts of static and chilly '80s synths display the
complicated frustration and sadness that comes with losing someone.
“Heartless”
and “Love Lockdown” are the album’s most car-stereo capable and glimpses of
what this album could’ve looked like if West set his ego aside and was willing
to do further editing. Between tribal drums thundering and vocal twitches,
“Love Lockdown” successfully samples this new concoction without being too
much. “Robocop” is disappointingly close to being another successful groove
with hints of West’s trademark snarky lyrics and punchy violins, but sinks to a
selfish jam session during the awkwardly endless bridge when West laments how
he will “never be a ruh-roh-bot.”
West’s
idea to invite 5-foot-nothing Top 40 jester Lil Wayne to this complex release
was another obvious misstep. As proven later in 2010 with his failed rock
attempt “Rebirth,” Wayne is really only successful at his staple version of
rap: sex, drugs and yes, auto tune. Their duet on this album, “See You In My
Knightmares,” is horribly one-note and edging on immature and dorky. “You think
your shit don't stank, but you are Mrs. P-U” Wayne recites. The attempt for
this song to be on any level of sophistication is immediately lost after his
verse, as predicted when first seeing “Featuring Lil Wayne” tacked on the
title.
But otherwise if you’re willing to
hear this thug-you-can-hug within this new context and are open to his
less-than-American-Idol quality of singing, “808s & Heartbreak”
fosters one of the most expressive and vulnerable releases from the egotistical
genre.
Drake, “Take Care” (Young Money
Entertainment and Cash Money Records 2011)
As another one of hip hop’s most
groundbreaking artists of today, Canadian actor-turned-rapper Aubrey “Drake”
Graham is also one of the most controversial artists introduced on the scene.
Loved by some, loathed by others, his arrival to success has sparked conversation
on the contemporary convergence hip hop and R&B, making Drake the figurehead
with his sweet singing and sensitive rhymes. But with as much attention comes
criticism: Drake is easily labeled as incompetent. Lil’ Kim has stated he ‘just
wasn’t built for this hood shit,’ and Common admitted his 2011 release “Sweet” was
written about him. The suggestion has been made that Drake’s singing has made him
less of an MC, and that he is perhaps too soft for contemporary hip hop.
His nonexistent criminal record and privileged
childhood have also forced Drake’s credibility as a rapper into disrepute. ‘His
art isn’t hard enough to be considered real hip hop.’ But Drake has proved his worth, as his artistic talent and courage to go outside the norm has had equally massive success in not
only mainstream audiences but underground fans as well.
Drake's 2011 release "Take Care" contains the most somber slow-jams out of his two major releases, simultaneously proving that hip hop and R&B can merge to a new undoubtedly successful genre that can generates support from snooty underground fans and hood rats alike.